Mid-Term Results of a Modern Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing Prosthesis
Krikler S & Nelson R (2005)
EFORT Oral presentation
A prospective single surgeon consecutive series of primary
resurfacing implantations in a UK district general hospital
setting. The surgeon resurfaces a range of patients
including challenging cases as, in the event of failure,
revision to a THR is relatively unchallenging.
345 resurfacings were performed (294 patients, 51 bilaterals),
no cases lost to follow-up, mean age at operation 52 years
(21-74 years) & 65% were male. There were 11 failures and 3
non-implant related deaths.
Mean follow-up was 29 months (3-79 months)
with a Kaplan-Meier survivorship of 94% at 7 years post-op.
Of the re-operations there were 5 fractured necks of femur
(all within 3 months of the index operation), 3 aseptic cup
loosenings, 2 femoral head collapses and 1 joint infection.
The fractured necks of femur and head collapse cases were
revised to a stemmed large headed THR articulating with the
retained metal acetabular component. The 3 loose cups were
revised to a larger size to articulate with the original
resurfacing femoral head and the single infected joint was
revised to a traditional THR.
This series is one of the longest using a currently
available device with encouraging medium term results. The
revision rates fall within the agreed national standards and
reflect the challenging nature of the cases involved.
The user remains cautiously optimistic about the long term
results of this resurfacing device.
Hydroxyapatite-Coated Femoral Implants in Metal-on-Metal
Resurfacing Hip Arthroplasty
Lilikakis AK, Vowler SL & Villar RN (2005)
Orthop Clin North Am. Apr; 36(2):pp215-22 (ix)
The authors report preliminary results of an uncemented,
hydroxyapatite-coated femoral implant for metal-on-metal hip
resurfacing.
The survival rate of 70 implants after at least 2 years
follow-up was 98.6%, with an excellent clinical outcome.
There have been no femoral fractures, aseptic loosening, or
radiolucencies around the stem. Thinning of the femoral neck
at the inferomedial cup-neck rim has been a frequent
radiological finding but with no clinical implication so
far. Longer follow-up is needed to confirm the results.
Internal Interim Summary of Multi-Centre Clinical Audit
Results
Krikler S, Bishay M, Pring D, Spencer R & Nelson R (2005)
Internal Corin Data Summary
Outcomes data was prospectively collected on a web based
Outcome Measures Database (OMD). 4 UK surgeons collected
clinical and radiological measures annually.
593 primary hip resurfacings were performed between Sept 1997
and Jan 2005 including 86 bilaterals. Mean age at surgery
was 52 years with a mean follow-up of 84 months. At 7 years
the Harris hip score mean value was 83 with a mean flexion
at last review of 99 degrees.
There were 14 revisions- 5 fractured neck of femurs, 5
aseptic cup loosenings, 2 collapsed femoral heads, 1
recurrent dislocation and 1 infection giving a Kaplan-Meier
survivorship of 94% (+5.2) @ 6 to 7 years post-op. The 5
fractured necks of femur and 2 collapsed femoral heads were
revised to large head stemmed devices retaining the original
cup. The 5 cup loosenings were upsized retaining the same
femoral heads. The recurrent dislocations and infection
cases were both revised to traditional total hip
replacements. No subsequent failures of these 14 revisions
have been recorded.
With acceptable post-op Harris Hip scores, hip flexion and
survivorship results the participating surgeons remain
cautiously optimistic regarding the long term performance of
the Cormet hip resurfacing system in this young, demanding
patient group.
Development, Validation and Multi-centre Follow-up of a
Modern Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing Prosthesis
Nevelos J, Nelson R, Shelton J, Krikler S, Bishay M, Banan
H, Pring D, Richardson J & Spencer R (2004)
AAOS Scientific Exhibit SE005
The original device was the McMinn Resurfacing Hip
(1991-1996) which was relaunched as the Cormet resurfacing
hip in 1997. Cormet is available in an increased range of
sizes with the cup coated in plasma sprayed titanium
overlaid with hydroxyapatite. Cups are available as pegged
or pegless and for the dysplastic hip.
The IRC in Biomaterials, Queen Mary, University of London
conducted two studies with Cormet. They looked firstly at
the effect of heat treatment of the device under standard
and severe conditions then at how bearing diameter affects
bearing lubrication properties. Heat treatment is applied to
orthopaedic devices to improve their surface wear
characteristics and the study showed that there was no
significant difference in the wear between heat treated and
non-heat treated devices under standard and severe test
conditions. The second study showed that bearing size did
have an effect on the wear characteristics of the bearing
with the larger diameter bearings having a lower long term
wear rate than conventional 28mm bearing.
Multi-Centre follow-up of prospectively collated data from
September 1997 to November 2003 covers 342 patients, average
age at op 55.5 years, 41 bilaterals, mean follow up 17
months. Mean modified Harris score at 5 years as a
percentage is 86% with 13 revisions giving a Kaplan-Meier
survivorship of 96% @ 7 years.
Metal ion release data was collected via a standardized
blood collection technique to ensure no metallic
contamination. 39 patients with 7 bilateral cases followed
up to 7 years. All patients had elevated levels of Cobalt
and Chromium immediately post-op although the extent of
increase was highly variable between individuals. The data
showed a marked trend of decreasing ion levels after 4 years
consistent with running-in wear. Patients <40 had slightly
higher ion levels than those >60, perhaps linked to age
related activity levels.
Development, Validation and Multi-centre Follow-up of a
Modern Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing Prosthesis
Nevelos J, Ahmad Y, Shelton J, Krikler S, Bishay M, Banan H,
Pring D, Richardson J & Spencer R. (2003)
AAOS Scientific Exhibition Abstract
Modern metal-on-metal hip resurfacing began in the early
1990’s with the McMinn Resurfacing Hip. Released in 1997,
the Cormet Resurfacing Hip is a development of the McMinn
hip.
In addition to clinical follow-up wear testing was carried
out with the effects of metallurgy and bearing diameter
tested under standard and severe conditions. Metal ion
release, a concern with all metal-on-metal bearings, is also
analysed in a 5 year study.
Between September 1997 and November 2002 209 primary
resurfacings took place in six centres. 207 patients were
followed up with no loss to follow-up. The average age at
operation was 52.9 years. There were 2 bilateral cases and 5
revisions with a revision rate of 2.3% at 5 years. Mean
follow-up was 32.5 months with an average Harris hip score
at last review of 78. Survivorship for Cormet was 98.9 at 3
years and 97.7 at 5 years.
Wear testing has shown that heat treatments do not increase
wear and that larger bearings have lower wear than 28mm
bearings. Also it was demonstrated that metal ion levels
decrease over time.
This device has been validated in vitro and the medium term
results are very encouraging.
Early Results of Total Hip Resurfacing via an Antero-lateral
Approach
Bishay M (2003)
EFORT Oral presentation
Data collated prospectively on the use of Cormet is
presented by a single user from Sept 1999 to July 2002. All
implantations were undertaken via an antero-lateral modified
Hardinge approach.
102 resurfacings were performed in 98 patients with an
average age of 42 years at operation. Mean pre-op Harris Hip
score was 58. Postoperatively 91 patients had a Harris Hip
Scores >92 and the remaining patients had a Harris Hip score
between 84 and 90. All working patients returned to
employment within 8 weeks, the self employed within 3-4
weeks. There was 1 cup dislodgement at 3 months post-op,
which was subsequently revised to a larger size.
The antero-lateral approach is quite adequate for exposure
and preparation and implantation of the resurfacing
component. Hip resurfacing should be considered as a
treatment option in young adults with arthritic hips.
However cases must be monitored for possible future
complications particularly those related to metal ion levels
in young females of child bearing potential.
Interim Clinical Results of the Cormet Resurfacing Hip
In 1997 the McMinn Resurfacing hip was redeveloped and
relaunched as the Cormet Resurfacing hip with the critical
design features being retained. Clinical results of the
McMinn Resurfacing hip have been published previously with a
97.4% survivorship at 6-7years.
7 surgeons followed the Cormet Hip Resurfacing in the UK
from September 1997 to May 2002. 191 cases were implanted
with mean follow-up of 15.5 months and the average of the
recipient was 51.7 years. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship
survival rate was 98.83% at 49 months and 97.2% at 3 years.
There were 5 failures in this series - 2 fractured necks of
femur, 1 dislocation and 2 acetabular loosenings.
The Cormet Resurfacing hip system offers an attractive
solution for the treatment of hip arthritis in the younger,
more active patient group.
Metal-on-Metal Resurfacing of the Hip with Hybrid Fixation
-
Our First 100 Consecutive Cases
McMinn DJW, Pynsent PB, De Cock CAEM, Isbister ES & Treacy
RBC. (2000)
SICOT Oral Presentation
The authors wished to determine if metal-on-metal
resurfacing arthroplasty of the hip performed better than
historic metal on polyethylene resurfacing designs.
Clinical and radiological assessment of the first 100 of 811
hybrid resurfacings was undertaken with a patient follow-up
of 45-61 months. Ave age at op was 48.5 years. All
procedures were conducted via a posterior approach without
trochanteric osteotomy.
Clinical and radiological outcomes are excellent with no
cases of dislocation, femoral neck fracture, avascular
necrosis or osteolysis. There was one infection and one
femoral loosening.
Early to medium term assessment indicate much better
outcomes than historical metal/polyethylene resurfacings.
Results of Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing
McMinn DJW, Pynsent PB, De Cock CAEM, Isbister ES & Treacy
RBC (2000)
JBJS 82-B (Orthopaedic Proceedings Suppliment II)
From March 1994 1085 consecutive resurfacings were performed
by the same surgeon, 294 were McMinn Resurfacings and 791
were Birmingham Hip Resurfacings. The mean age at operation
was 53 years.
Of the 294 McMinn Resurfacings there were 5 failures- 2
infections, 2 cup loosenings and one femoral head collapse
in a patient with pre-existing AVN.
Of the 791 Birmingham Hip Resurfacings there were 5
failures- 4 femoral neck fractures and one collapsed femoral
head from AVN. The cumulative survivorship in this group was
98% @ 5-6 years.
Analysis of the migration of the cup was undertaken using
the Nunn method. Migration of the resurfacing cup was
0.015mm/yr N.S.D. to Harris Galante cups. On the femoral
side migration of the cemented resurfacing component was
compared to that of the Exeter cemented stem using the
Walker method. The resurfacing components migrated
significantly less than the Exeter components, 0.031mm/yr
and 0.098 respectively (p=0.022).
Of 206 Birmingham patients (27 bilateral) surveyed the mean
time taken to return to work post-operatively was 7.1 weeks
and 169 patients were participating in recreational sport.
Hip resurfacing using metal-on-metal hybrid fixed components
offers a viable treatment for the young patient with hip
arthritis.